top of page

Why Aren't We Treating Op Shops Like Serious Retail?

3 hours ago
5 min read

An estimated $310 million worth of goods resold in a year. More than 1,000 stores. More than 1,550 full-time-equivalent volunteers. Put those numbers on a fashion chain and every retailer in the country would know its name.


This isn't a chain. It's the op shop sector, and the industry still files it under charity. That is a blind spot. We drop off the bags, say thanks, and carry on talking about Trade Me and Facebook Marketplace.


Hands with rings browse colorful clothes on hangers, including jeans and denim jackets, in a crowded closet or boutique.

Yes, op shops take in pre-loved goods and sell them for a fraction of the price. But they do far more than that. They fund hospice care, keep 41,300 tonnes of goods out of landfill and provide 1,322 full-time-equivalent paid jobs.


This year the sector launched a national body and published its first impact study.

It is also in a fight over prices, town-centre saturation, card fees and a tide of fast fashion in the donation bins. Those are retail problems, not charity problems.


So here is the question the industry keeps avoiding: if op shops are a sector, why isn't anyone treating them like one?


Big enough to need a trade body


Start with the numbers, because they are bigger than most people expect.


According to Hospice NZ's summary, op shops reused 46.9 million items in a year and kept 41,300 tonnes out of landfill. They put $78 million into social and community services, hospice care included. They provide 1,322 full-time-equivalent paid jobs, backed by more than 1,550 full-time-equivalent volunteers. The study values the goods resold at an estimated $310 million and puts household savings at $844 million.


Charitable Reuse Aotearoa, a collaboration of seven of New Zealand's largest charitable reuse organisations, is the new national voice for charity retail. Its job list is advocacy, member capability, public education and impact measurement. It says there are over 1,000 op shops in the country.


You don't build a lobbying arm and a data programme for a church-hall stall. You build them for an industry.


How big is the secondhand market? Depends who you ask.


Trade Me's 2026 Circular Economy report puts the value of circular economy at $5.2 billion. The Spinoff notes that Stats NZ counted just $232 million through antique and secondhand retailers in the year to September 2025, and that this undercounts the market.


Scale changes things. A sector this size gets competition, pricing pressure and policy risk, the same as any other part of retail. The question is whether anyone is managing them. I count four pressure points, and the most visible one is in the shop window.


Is the op shop getting too posh?


Take the Remuera Mercy Hospice shop. It looks more boutique than op shop, and that is certainly deliberate. Right execution for the right location.


Bright thrift store with clothing racks and display shelves of glassware, plates and art; COVID-19 poster on the wall.
Remuera Mercy Hospice Shop. Image source: opshops.co

Mercy's For Mercy stores were seen as outdated and not worth the rummage. So agency True built the "Nothing New for Good" campaign around them: a styling workshop, editorial photography and a store design refresh. The stores' own line, relayed in Campaign Brief, is that they would not have reached 15% sales growth without it.


Credit where it is due. I like it as retail: sharper presentation, tighter curation, a clear stand against fast fashion, and a pitch to the shopper who would otherwise be on a resale app. The extra margin helps fund the hospice. But here is what I keep coming back to: who is the new shop for?


I have no problem with op shops getting nicer. My worry is the people they were built for getting priced out while the rest of us applaud the rebrand. I know that our some of our RX team and their kids trawl the stores and resell on Depop. But the great finds are getting less (apparently).


Five op shops, one town of 4,000


Posh is one pressure. Crowding is another.


Retail has a name for this: cannibalisation. Nobody uses it when the competitors are all charities. In 2017, SunLive reported from Katikati, a town of about 4,000, where a fifth op shop was about to open.


The manager of the Goodlife Opportunity Shop, 31 years in the same town, said business had halved. She had already cut the shop's monthly foodbank donation from $250 to $150 and trimmed grants to local service groups. She didn't begrudge the new hospice shop, she said, and expected it to get a sympathy vote.


That story is nine years old and I couldn't find a recent follow-up, so read it as a case study, not a current count.


Still, it frames the problem better than anything newer. Donated stock is free, but shoppers and shop floors aren't. Every new charity shop in a small town fights for the same bargain hunters and the same donors.


In Katikati, the older shop's community giving shrank with its takings. Every cause behind every shop is worthy, and I think that is exactly why nobody wants to be the one to say a town has enough. That is how a town ends up with five.


The card fee nobody can pass on


Now for a squeeze that has nothing to do with stock.


The Government's ban on surcharging contactless card payments in store, due from 2026, takes away the lever most retailers use to cover card fees. Hospice NZ says the cost lands on charity retailers, who can't negotiate fees, refuse a payment method or put up prices on donated goods the way an ordinary shop might. It also says hospice shops bring in about half of hospices' charitable income, and warns the ban could cost the sector millions in funding for care.


Its ask: a targeted exemption for registered charities, a subsidy or reimbursement of merchant fees, and a proper consultation. I couldn't find that an exemption has been granted.


Close-up of a hand using a card reader on paperwork at a checkout counter, with people standing nearby in a bright store

A charity can’t negotiate its card fees, can’t turn cards away and can’t put up prices on donated goods the way an ordinary shop can. Every percentage point comes straight out of the money that funds care.


Did anyone intend that when the surcharge ban was written? It’s a fair question for the people who wrote it.


Your cast-offs, their bill


And then there's the stock.


Fast fashion has made clothes cheap enough to treat as disposable, and a lot of it ends up in donation bins. An op shop is a retailer with free inputs, so stock quality is its cost of goods. When the input gets worse, the bill moves to sorting, storage and disposal. Someone pays it, and it isn't the person who dropped the bag off.


A 2023 Auckland Council study estimated 33,975 tonnes of clothing are donated to op shops a year. Only about 20% is good enough to sell. Some stores are turning items away, asking whether they are saleable, not just wearable. A couple of reuse shops have stopped taking certain fast-fashion labels.


Charities are spending money to handle goods they can't sell, and most of the people filling the bins think they're helping.


Schemes like The Good Drop give worn-out and low-value clothing somewhere to go that isn't a volunteer's sorting table. That leaves the op shop to do what it is good at: reselling clothes people will actually wear.


It will take that, plus a public nudge that donating is not the same as dumping.


The full life of a garment, and who's minding it


Unsold new stock is one end of the story. Take-back, through schemes like The Good Drop, is the other. Op shops handle the big messy middle of everything Kiwis pass on. That middle is the part of the story with a thousand-plus doors. They are also the least studied.


Nobody doubts that op shops do good. My question is whether the sector is set up to keep doing it: priced so the people it was built for can still shop there, spaced so towns don't cannibalise their own giving, protected from a card-fee rule written with ordinary retailers in mind, and stocked with things worth selling.


Mainstream retail has spent a decade chasing a share of resale. The op shops were already there, running on donated stock and volunteers. I think they have earned a proper look from the rest of us.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page