Doing good isn’t a department
Two Massey University studies point to the same thing: the retailers that change anything are the ones where purpose is the business, not a bolt-on.
Most retailers I speak to want to do good. Ask where that sits in the business and the answers can vary – a lot. A campaign here, a charity partnership there, a line in the annual report. Useful, sometimes, but not the same as a retailer that is built around it.
Professor Nitha Palakshappa, Doctor Sarah Dodds and Doctor Andrew Murphy at Massey University have spent years asking what the difference looks like in practice. I have been delighted to work alongside them as an industry sponsor to support bringing their incredibly insights into applied learning for the industry. Their latest work will be shared at an event we are currently planning, so I asked the team for the thinking behind it. Here is what their earlier research says, and what Nitha told me when I put five questions to her.
Purpose first, everything else second
In a 2022 study in the Journal of Service Theory and Practice, Sarah Dodds, Nitha Palakshappa and Loren Stangl looked at four New Zealand sustainable fashion brands: Untouched World, Icebreaker, WE’AR and Kowtow. They spoke with founders and senior managers about how these businesses actually work.
Three themes stood out: an embedded core purpose, alignment between a brand’s values and the people it works with (the researchers call it relevance of fit), and the breadth and depth of the message. The first did the heavy lifting. As one of the leaders put it, “sustainability is innate”. It is not a department. It is the reason the business exists.

That clarity has a practical payoff. The researchers found that managers with a sustainability-centred purpose face less tension in decisions such as who to collaborate with, what fibres to use or even where to sell. The brands took a “no compromise” stance, and two of them were design-led rather than chasing trends, as a fast fashion business might.
Two other details stayed with me. These leaders deliberately started their messaging from positivity, telling stories of collective hope rather than leading with a negative angle like global warming. And one saw sustainability as something that “should be the right of entry industry standard”. Expected, not boasted about.
A caution before we start quoting Patagonia
Both studies are small, qualitative and focused on purpose-led fashion brands, and the Instagram data comes from 2020. They show what is possible when intent and values line up, not what every retailer will find. Nitha’s view, below, is that purpose-led fits whatever the size of the business.
Doing Good in Retail – latest study
This year RX Group has joined Massey University as Industry Research Partner on Doing Good in Retail, a study led by Professor Nitha Palakshappa, Dr Sarah Dodds and Dr Andrew Murphy from Massey’s School of Management and Marketing.
The team’s earlier work looked at sustainability and transformative service in fashion retail. This study takes those ideas into mainstream retail, where margins are tight and every decision has a commercial trade-off attached.
At its heart is one question: how do retailers create genuine social and environmental value while staying commercially viable, and what actually gets in the way?

The research sets out to understand how retailers define and prioritise doing good, to identify the organisational, customer and system-level barriers holding them back, and to lay the groundwork for a practical, evidence-based tool that helps retailers act on it within real commercial parameters.
Some of New Zealand’s best-known retailers are taking part, with leaders from buying, supply chain and sustainability sharing how these decisions really get made. The findings land in early 2027, and we can’t wait to share them.
Five questions for Nitha Palakshappa
Nitha is Professor of Marketing and Sustainability at Massey University. I asked her five questions on behalf of the research team. Her answers, in her words:
What made you want to study doing good in mainstream retail?
Mainstream retail offers a powerful platform that reaches a wider cross-section of people. Retailers that are ‘doing good’ are able to access this ‘audience’ to create real transformation.
What’s the biggest misconception retailers have about sustainability?
The big retailers that we speak to don’t necessarily demonstrate misconceptions about sustainability - they understand that we are at a crucial juncture in protecting all aspects of sustainability. The smaller retailers might understand the importance of sustainability, act earnestly to do what they can, but often struggle through lack of resources to implement.
What is pertinent is the consumer angle - many still see sustainability as simple environmental issues, e.g. ‘let’s not use single-use plastic bags’. What they often miss is the hidden cost - who has made my $10 t-shirt and where does it come from … the provenance story is missing in the minds of the consumer. Many retailers are often involved in initiatives (e.g. modern slavery) that are consequently missed by most consumers.

Your published work is mostly with purpose-led brands. What do you expect changes in larger retailers?
Whilst some of our recent work has shed light on how small purpose-led brands navigate the tensions and paradox of sustainability, we strongly believe that purpose-led fits regardless of organisational size. This is clear when we start to unpack exemplary global brands such as Patagonia.
Many larger retailers may not be purpose-led but we would suggest a strong commitment to be sustainable is a true positive. The transition towards sustainability is not a short-term goal - it is a complex and long-term commitment.
What would you love retail leaders to do differently after reading the findings?
We would pose the question - what is your purpose? What is your commitment to sustainability? Once this is clear and filtered from top to bottom it is easier to make operational decisions that align.
Why should a busy retail exec come along in February?
These conversations are important and everyone has a contribution to make. We learn from sharing - things that have worked but also challenges faced.
Four questions to take back to your leadership team
The research and Nitha’s answers point in one direction. Before the next campaign or partnership, try these.
What is our purpose, and could everyone in the business say it in a sentence?
Where does it sit: in our strategy and daily decisions, or in a report?
Does the cause we back fit who we are and who our customers are, or would they call it tokenistic?
Are we telling the whole story, including the hidden costs behind what we sell?
Doing good is easier to talk about than to build into a business. The research suggests the order matters: start with purpose, check the fit, then tell the story.
Read the research
Palakshappa, N., Bulmer, S. and Dodds, S. (2024), “Co-creating sustainability: transformative power of the brand”, Journal of Marketing Management. doi.org/10.1080/0267257X.2024.2380261
Dodds, S., Palakshappa, N. and Stangl, L.M. (2022), “Sustainability in retail services: a transformative service research (TSR) perspective”, Journal of Service Theory and Practice, 32(4), 521-544. doi.org/10.1108/JSTP-12-2021-0255
About the researchers
Nitha Palakshappa is Professor of Marketing and Sustainability at Massey University. Her research sits under an umbrella of sustainability and social responsibility. Sarah Dodds researches services marketing, in particular transformative service research, including topics such as wellbeing, sustainability and consumer vulnerability. Andrew Murphy is part of the Massey team behind the current research project.




Comments